Tuesday, March 29, 2011

The Decision is Final

We are going to have our 5 year old repeat Kindergarten.  Mommy is going to get over it and then tell the boy.  My husband and I know that he will be a little upset with us at first, but we really think this will benefit him in the long run.  We are concerned about his social maturity (he is one of the youngest in his class, making the "cut-off" by just 6 weeks) and his ability to "hold it together" for a whole day.  His school offers both 1/2 day Kindergarten and full day Kindergarten.  He goes full day 2 days a week and is 1/2 day the rest of the week.  Next year we will have him go full day each day.  Right now he has a hard time holding it together in the afternoon which consists of lunch, recess, and rest time, along with some reinforcement of the week's lessons.   We are afraid that he will have trouble focusing and not melting down in 1st in the afternoon and essentially "miss" the instruction.  He's a very bright little boy which makes this harder for us and for us to explain to our family.  They don't get it.  His pediatrician doesn't either.  I have read the current body of research that states it's horrible to hold a kid back. But I haven't seen this in the kids I know that were held back. And is it better to push a child along whom is going to struggle and feel "behind" most of the time?  We think not.....and well this is one of those times we cannot know both ways.  We can only speculate....and pray we have made the best decision.....

4 comments:

  1. I am the mother of a 5 year old that is going into Pre-K, not Kindergarten. He is 95%ile in height, and already the biggest kid in his class. But. I feel like now is the time to go slow. I'm not concerned about academics now or later. The schools have a pathway for kids that can learn above grade level. However, there is no alternate social pathway for a child to "catch up" on the social curriculum. That's trial by fire on the courtroom of the playground. Therefore, I feel good about having a 6 year old kindergartener. I also know enough others doing it that I know my child will not be the ONLY one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh I know he will not be the only one-in fact I know one that is 6 weeks younger, and one that has a birthday just before his. He has at least 4 "friends" coming into K with him next year. I am not sure why I bothers me. Probably because we struggled with the decision to put him in K in the first place, and it is gonna hurt him a little for him to not go along with his "friends" from this year.
    Academically, he is doing great-he has been sight reading since just before he turned 5, but it's the social stuff and maturity that concerns his dad and I (both of us are teachers too). My son is one of the smallest in his class-about 3 1/2 feet tall and not quite 40 pounds!
    We know this will be best for him...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think it's a great idea. I *know* beyond a shadow of a doubt that you have his best interest at heart and really think it will benefit him over the rest of his schooling.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks-MamaOAB :D We think so too.

    ReplyDelete